Audience Rating: G (General Audience)
Binding: VHS Tape
EAN: 9786301978255
Format: Color
ISBN: 6301978250
Label: MGM (Video & DVD)
Manufacturer: MGM (Video & DVD)
Number Of Items: 1
Publisher: MGM (Video & DVD)
Release Date: 1998-09-01
Running Time: 76
Studio: MGM (Video & DVD)
Theatrical Release Date: 1949-10-31

Customer Rating:
Summary: A collie replaces a terrier
Comment: To set the record straight for viewers, this movie took the story of Greyfriars Bobby, a terrier who stayed at his master's grave in Edinburgh for 14 years, and re-did it with 'Lassie,' because Disney Studios wanted a vehicle for their famous canine. This takes nothing away from the charm of the story and the sheer pleasure of watching Lassie perform, but it should be recognized that there was a genuine and loyal Yorkshire terrier who was buried at the Edinburgh cemetery beside his master, and whose devotion has been memorialized by a statue in Edinburgh.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Successful drama yet also thought-provoking
Comment: We watched Challenge to Lassie on VHS 54 years after its release, and having also recently seen the latest Matrix and Lord of the Rings films.

What a contrast! There is something utterly charming about this simple, hour-and-15-minute film from another era without a single wasted moment or fancy SFX or eternal subplots

Lassie as a puppie is adorable (full disclosure: my husband and I have two shelties, one a gigantic near-twin of Lassie, with his honey coat and white blaze and flapping ears). As an adult, she acts quite like our shelties, who tug us by the wrist, whimper and bark and paw our knees to communicate. Sheepdog owners will recognize a lot of their intelligent companions in the 1949 movie version Lassie. This Lassie doesn't have the comically overblown talent of the TV version, so aptly parodized by Mad magazine (wherein Lassie fills out the tax returns for the ranch). She is instead quite clever in a way realistic to the various Scottish herding dogs.

Her master Jock is scrupulously honest; and Lassie a paragon of devotion.


"Challenge" also contains a little morality play demonstrating the legal principle that bad cases make bad law. After Jock's murder, a panel of Edinburgh judges want to put down the ownerless dog because technically no one can buy her the required collar and tag. Much like the Biblical mockery of the Pharisees as heartless technocrats, tenement children arrive to point out the absurdity of the court.

This is a little jewel of a movie -- as the earlier reviewer states it is good family entertainment but to a pair of adult viewers it also held its own as a quality film.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Saved By A Multitude Of Friends
Comment: CHALLENGE TO LASSIE is a fairly entertaining family film about Lassie's loyalty to her master even after the latter's death. The biggest danger to Lassie comes from the local law enforcement officials who want to kill her because she no longer has the proper license. Lassie gets all of the help she really needs from a group of concerned villagers, a nearby garrison of soldiers and a host of gutsy children.

Edmund Gwenn stars as the dog's chief advocate and a strong supporting cast includes Donald Crisp, Alan Webb, Alan Napier, Henry Stephenson, Sarah Allgood, Geraldine Brooks and Reginald Owen. Richard Thorpe is known as a competent director of many movies including IVANHOE and THE STUDENT PRINCE.

---